US Financial Warfare Has Been Very Effective in Starving Russia of Foreign Investments
So much so that the undercapitaized Moscow stock market is now the world's biggest bargain
Foreign direct investment (FDI) into Russia continues to decline: at the end of last year it fell threefold to its lowest level in the last decade. The net outflow of foreign investment was the highest since 2014 and amounted to $23.1bn, according to the Central Bank of Russia (CBR).
Foreign investment should be a powerful driver of growth and Russia needs to grow as currently growth is capped at about 2% according to experts – well below the speed of global growth. The Russian economy is stagnating and is now starting to slowly fall behind the rest of the world.
President Vladimir Putin has specifically tasked the government to increase the rate of growth so that it is faster than that of the rest of the world. According to official forecasts growth will reach 3.1% in 2021, but few economists are confident that that target will be met.
However, if the government’s plans to implement the 12 national projects is successful then by 2024 Russia should be in the top five economies in Europe and growing faster than the global average. But is this goal possible to achieve without foreign investment?
“I first came to Russia in 1966 and I was pessimistic about Russia for 46 years. Now I’m an optimist,” well known fund manager Jim Rogers told a round table of investors organised by the Russian paper Vedomosti on August 28 in central Moscow. “I like Russia because it has lots of bears — everyone else hates it, which is usually a good sign for investors. It is a country with every resource known to man and it is very cheap. That is a winning combination.”
Rogers argued that the sanctions imposed on Russia in 2014 have lead to some great opportunities, especially in agriculture.
“Russian farmers are blessing Trump’s name every day as they have to do well as a result of the sanctions,” Rodgers told the participants. “I have investments. I am buying Russian stocks as we speak today. Russia is probably one of the best places to invest. We are probably going to have tough times in the world. Citi says there is a 66% chance of a global recession in the coming years, but when that happens Russia will be least affected. Partly because the prices have already gone down and partly because of the restructuring that has already happened.”
Chief economist for Russia at Citibank, Ivan Tchakarov, points out that, ”after 2014 Russia has achieved macro stability and it is stable. But if you ask people about the future then they say growth at most at 1-1.5% — not very exciting. But the real achievement has been to bring the breakeven price of oil for the budget down to $50-55. That is really spectacular.”
Tchakarov goes on to point out that over the long-term the average price of oil has been $35 and that lower prices are normal. Moreover, while Russia has been underperforming the other emerging markets recently, if you compare it to the other commodity exporters then it has actually been outperforming or at least level with its peers.
The Russian stock market has been doing very well this year and is up some 30% YTD. The bond market has also been very popular, with foreign investors piling into the market to take their share of outstanding Ministry of Finance OFZ treasury bills to 30%. But as the government is currently running a large 2% budget surplus and is a awash with money that is not really the type of investment Russia needs.
“The attractiveness of the portfolio investment is clear, but that is different from investing and operating a company in Russia. The bigger you are the easier it is to work, but the smaller you are the more difficult it gets,” Alexis Rodzianko, president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Russia, tells participants. “You make most money when things go from terrible to just bad. Geopolitical risk just has to remain the same for portfolio investors to be happy, but that is not true for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). I think the government is circling the wagons and getting ready for disaster rather than fostering growth.”
Rodzianko sums up the problem that the Russian story looks very different depending on what your point of view is. The macro stability encourages bond investors, but the slow growth dissuades equity investors, even if the market is up this year, as it remains extremely cheap, according to Dmtri Sedov, the chairman of Goldman Sachs, Russia. “This is one of the cheapest markets in the world if you look at it in terms of the multiples. Investors are paying attention to this.”
Life is harder for the companies that are actually making something, but Stuart Lawson, former head of HSBC in Russia and now on the board of the European Businesses Association, points out that Russia’s negative image masks the attractive nature of the market.
“Two types foreign investors: there are the guys that are here and the guys thinking of coming,” says Lawson, who has been working in Russia for about two decades. “If you are here then you reinvest everything you make into growing your business. If you are overseas and looking at Russia then there is a reluctance to even come and look at the market. So what determines the offshore view? The media to a large extent set the image. The foreign media do a real job on Russia. If there is a demo on Tverskaya then that is a front page story and it’s what the board of directors see.”
Russia remains a difficult place to work and Lawson and other participants in the Vedomosti round table point out that the operating environment is tough, especially for smaller companies. But because of the size of the market, and also thanks to the higher barriers to entry, it is also a very profitable market.
“The big companies are investing for the long-term,” says Lawson. “The automotive producers have increased their investment on the basis of special investment deals with the government. But those contracts run over a five to seven year time period. They are looking at the long-term horizon. To make that work the government needs a predictable set of values to encourage long-term horizon investment. The climate has to be predictable.”
And there is a rub. The long-term horizon predictability took a big hit with the arrest of US fund manager and founder of Baring Vostok Capital Partners (BVCP) Michael Calvey on Valentine’s Day this year. Calvey got caught up in a corporate dispute with his co-investors into Orient Express Bank (OEB, aka Vostochniy Bank).
“That was a purely an economic dispute that should have been settled in the arbitration courts. It was not a criminal affair and the use of the criminal courts was deliberate,” says ombudsman for business Boris Titov, who has been actively lobbying for Calvey’s release.
Calvey has been released to house arrest and his colleague, Frenchman Philippe Delpal, was also released from pre-trial detention on August 15, just before Putin travelled to France to meet French President Emmanuel Macron.
The Calvey affair was a heavy blow to Russia’s investment image. Rodzianko says that US companies that were already in Russia didn’t leave, but they have paused investment plans to see how the story pans out. Fund managers interviewed by bne IntelliNews in Moscow tell a similar story, saying that fundraising has been suspended thanks to the uncertainties the arrest has raised. For its part, BVCP says it is not pulling out of Russia and will continue to invest, but it is working to get its staff out of jail.
“The case doesn’t just involve Calvey as six people were arrested. Calvey, Delpal and four more Russian colleagues,” says Elena Ivashentseva, a senor partner at BVCP. “It is unacceptable to use criminal law in a corporate dispute. We are grateful to Boris Titov for his support and that Michael was released to house arrest, but there are still four of our Russian colleagues in jail.”
Ivashentseva said that BVCP is not pulling out of Russia and continues to invest.
“The market is only 30 years old. It has only been a bit less than 30 years since the mechanisms of the market economy started to develop,” says Ivashentseva. “Investors don’t fully understand the potential of the market. You have been talking about the slow pace of economic growth but the kind of companies we invest into – the fintech, IT, telecom, banking and retail companies – are all growing at 30% a year or more. They can double revenue in a year. Yet the SMEs make up only 25% of GDP. In the west it’s more like 50-60%. We are staying in Russia. We have $3bn assets under management. We will continue to invest.”
Source: bne IntelliNews